Supplier Spotlight

Show Reviews

Automotive Testing Expo Europe 2017 Show Review

Click here to read


Automotive Testing Expo Europe 2016 Show Review

Click here to read


Automotive Testing Expo Europe 2015 Show Review

Click here to read


Automotive Testing Expo North America 2014 Show Review

Click here to read


Automotive Testing Expo India 2014 Show Review

Click here to read


Latest Video

Groupe Renault reveals Symbioz prototype


Symbioz features Level 4 automation and will be used by Renault to test and develop autonomous vehicle functions and technologies

Click here to watch the video

TRI's next-gen automated research vehicle


Engineers explain their goals for Platform 3.0, which included to radically increase the car's sensor capabilities

Click here to watch the video

Will dynamic watermarks be the solution to cyber attack threats on autonomous vehicles?

Industry Opinion

« back to blog listings

Making one's point

Hackers, pranksters and the role of sheer chance mean that car developers are entering a long-term phase of trial and error. The future of autonomous cars, and all the safety and reliability benefits this is due to bring, will be dependent on overcoming a whole stream of threats and attacks, says Dr Stefano Longo, senior lecturer in vehicle control and optimization at the Advanced Vehicle Engineering Centre, Cranfield University, UK.

Performance artist James Bridle caused a flurry of interest – and delight – with his video clip ‘Autonomous trap 001’. A white circle was made on a side road using salt, comprising a full circle on the inside and a dashed line on the outside. The resulting film showed a car driving into the circle and sitting there transfixed within the ‘magical’ limits of the complete line, a technology trapped by a rule-bound semi-intelligence.

It was an exercise intended to highlight the limitations of technology, and any form of artificial intelligence in particular. On the one hand it’s an unfair criticism – the car used in the film wasn’t even an AV, and the AI technology is already available which would enable the car to see and recognize when it was being trapped in this way. On the other hand, there’s a darker significance. This was just a cheeky stunt, but it’s a signal of what’s coming: a battle between autonomous car design and the threats and challenges from a sometimes ugly real world.

In themselves, roads are obviously far more complex than just tracks for transportation, [that takes the form of] regular movement in regular patterns. The unpredictable behavior of human-controlled vehicles is the single most challenging factor: drivers are emotional, tired, irrational, potentially even intentionally malicious. And that’s just the start.

The spectrum of weather conditions just in the UK, let alone globally, is very wide, and each will need to be recognized and understood by an AV in terms of how it can ‘read’ the roadway. No matter how much an AV system ‘learns’ about the look and habits of the world there will always be potential for the unexpected – a burst tire in the road, a cyclist weaving in and out of traffic, pedestrians trying to cross a road in an unusual spot, a falling rock from a hillside.

These are all relatively predictable sets of challenges for an AV. The other area of threats is hackers and pranksters. As AVs slowly evolve and become more of a common and accepted feature of our roads the limitations of AI are going to be exposed.

Most crudely we know that driverless cars are going to be a target for people wanting to make a joke of them, proving their inability to hurt pedestrians by walking into the road in front of them (a highly dangerous trick that could cause a chain reaction of accidents).

But the reality is that, at this stage, we don’t know what all the ‘salt circle’ traps might be. In theory, there is the ability for hackers to interfere with radar systems, the networks of sensors and inter-vehicle communications that vehicles rely on.

Critically then, we’re entering a rigorous phase of testing and learning; the development of banks of sophisticated knowledge that will toughen AVs for the real world – combining efficiency with values-based, ‘human’ decision making.

Part of the frontline of the battle is at the new Multi-User Environment for Autonomous Vehicle Innovation (MUEAVI) test site (see the November issue of ATTI). MUEAVI is a mile of smart roadway running through the Cranfield University campus and the US$11.8m (£9m) development is due to be operational from October this year.

It’s unique in terms of being a ‘living lab’, a new arterial road for the site that is in everyday use by vehicles and pedestrians and rigged and ready with AV systems. One of the first test projects will be the Innovate UK-funded HumanDrive, which exposes AVs to threats from both expected and unexpected real-world conditions.

November 15, 2017



There are currently no comments.

If you would like to post a comment about this blog, please click here.
Read Latest Issue
Read Latest Issue

Your email address:

Web Exclusives

Keep it on the hush

Volvo uses LMS Test.Lab software to better understand the source of noise emissions
Click here to read more

Improved leakage testing

New technology from Sensing Precision helps reduce potential bottlenecks in production associated with cabin leakage testing
Click here to read more

Ford's plans to return home

Key autonomous and electric vehicle business and strategy teams are be moved to the city where the Blue Oval began its life
Click here to read more

Safer analysis of onboard chargers

How Keysight's compact, two-quadrant, regenerative power converter test solution with integrated safety features accelerates test time, and protects both users and devices under test
Click here to read more

SEAT uses HBM autonomous DAQ system

SEAT and Polytechnic University of Catalonia (BarcelonaTech) have jointly developed a unique data acquisition enabling more precise control over instrumented parts and the entire data acquisition process  
Click here to read more

Supplier Spotlight

Supplier SpotlightClick here for listings and information on leading suppliers covering all aspects of the automotive testing industry. Want to see your company included? Contact for more details.

Submit your industry opinion

Industry BlogDo you have an opinion you'd like to share with the automotive testing community? Good or bad, we'd like to hear your views and opinions on the leading issues shaping the industry. Share your comments by sending up to 500 words to


Recruitment AdTo receive information on booking an advertising banner please email